Robert Anton Wilson and Robert Shea. Blog, Internet resources, online reading groups, articles and interviews, Illuminatus! info.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

'Green Egg' fan Robert Heinlein writes to Oberon Zell

 


Robert Heinlein, left, with two other "Golden Age" authors at the Philadelphia Naval Yard in 1944. L. Sprague de Camp is in the center and Isaac Asimov is on the right. (Public domain photo).

[One of the pleasures of writing a blog such as this one is running across some interesting people, at least on the Internet if not in person. I've exchanged emails with Oberon Zell (Oberon Zell-Ravenheart, Timothy Zell), which I think is kind of cool.

Zell, 83, co-founded the Church of All Worlds, inspired by the religion in Robert Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land. He founded the pagan magazine Green Egg, which had contributions by Robert Anton Wilson. He has written a bunch of books on magick. He was the guest star for one of my favorite Hilaritas Press podcasts.  He's endorsed the latest RAW book, Maybe Magick.  See him discussing polyamory in the comments for this blog post. 

Oh, and did you know Robert Heinlein wrote to him? After I listened to the aforementioned Hilaritas Podcasts, I wrote to him and asked how to read the letters Heinlein wrote to him. He kindly sent me the text of two long letters. I finally remembered to ask him if I could post them here, and he gave permission!

I love these letters. Here they are. The Mgt.]

Robert A. Heinlein to Oberon (Tim) Zell, 1/20/72 (This entire letter, along with my initial letter to Mr. Heinlein, to which this was in reply, was printed in Green Egg Vol. XXI, No. 82; Lughnasadh, 1988)

Dear Mr. Zell:

Thank you for your warmly pleasing letter. I have enjoyed reading the GREEN EGG and have been stimulated by it. Yes, the early material you mentioned I would enjoy seeing. No hurry--I am always about half a ton behind in the periodicals and books I must read in order to write intelligently. They print it faster than I can read it.

So you went to Westminster in Fulton? “Small World” note: one of my aunts had the history department there many years ago (she would be more than a hundred now, were she still alive). I have a brother living about twenty miles from there—Major General L.L. Heinlein, Retired. I was born in Butler, south of Kansas City, grew up in K.C., and was appointed from there to the Naval Academy, and have hardly been in Missouri since—save for quick trips to act as a pallbearer; my contemporaries are dying off.

Quote: “--friends of ours in science fiction fandom assured us that not only would you not be interested in our endeavors, but most likely hostile to them, and that you had expressed antagonism to other emerging ‘nests’ and ‘water-brotherhoods’ that had contacted you.”

This is utter nonsense throughout.

Facts:

1. The last time I was present at any organized SF fandom meeting was in Seattle in 1961 plus a very brief appearance at Chicago in 1962 to accept the Hugo for STRANGER--brief because I showed up at the last minute, having been busy at NASA Houston on some writing for the Gemini program. STRANGER was published in 1961. If there were any “nests” or such by Labor Day 1962, I was unaware of them. My contact with organized fandom since that day has been zero.

2. Before 1962 my contact with organized fandom was slight. I went several times to meetings of the LASFS in 1939-40 and went to the convention in 1940 or -411. Check: 1941, at Denver, as I recall now that I was in the east at that time in 1940. After 1940 the next contact that I recall was (I believe) in 1958--a meeting in Newark--then again at Chicago in 1960, to receive a Hugo. I think that sums up the total of my contacts with organized fandom, although I have forgotten some casual appearances, as the period spans 33 years and I kept no records on it. But I am certain that my last appearance at a meeting was ten years ago.

3. Contacts with individuals, fans of SF who may or may not have been part of organized fandom: There have been many of these, by letter, in my home, in other people’s homes, or elsewhere: There have been more fan contacts in the past than in recent years, because of pressure of work and loss of time caused by illness. In many cases I do not know whether a stranger I have met (in person or by letter) is or is not a member of organized fandom. In some cases I’ve learned it later (too late!) through learning that a private letter of mine has been published in one of those fan magazines, or have found that casual, social remarks have been treated, without my consent or review, as an “interview” and published in a garbled form...

4. As a result of the above we have become somewhat more cautious in recent years in our social contacts and in the letters we write, especially as the pressure from strangers has become much greater. I have to live behind a locked gate and with an unlisted phone to get any work done at all--and this is a hell of a note as my wife and I are by nature quite gregarious and social. Mrs. Heinlein usually answers and signs all of the mail, which tends to discourage the incipient “pen pals” who would, if allowed, take up all my time and leave none for writing. A rare exception, such as your letter, I answer myself. We necessarily find our social life among people who don’t read science fiction.

5. All of the above adds up to this: There are very, very few people in organized fandom who know anything at all about me in the sense of knowing me personally or in being privy to my private opinions, tastes, or habits. My published works are widespread and anyone can read them. The public facts about my life are in several reference books in most public libraries. But a member of science fiction fandom is most unlikely to know any more about me than you do, and if he claims otherwise, he is almost certainly talking through his hat.

6. But I am repeatedly amazed at the number of people who claim to be “experts” on me. (One of them even wrote an entire book about me. I have never met him in my life.)

7. I have never expressed “antagonism” or hostility to “nests” or “water-brotherhoods.” This is sheer fabrication. I would like to throw such a lie into the teeth of anyone saying so, if I knew who he were.

8. On the contrary, a number of “nests” have indeed gotten into contact with me. I have treated them with politeness. I have standing invitations from several to visit them. I think I am on good terms with every such organization which has taken the trouble to get into touch with me. If you have any specific data to the contrary, I would like to hear it, in detail. (But I have no way to deal with malicious allegations from faceless, nameless strangers.)

STRANGER: It is a work of fiction in parable form. It is not a “put-on” unless you choose to classify every work of fiction as such. Who are these persons who allege this? I would like an opportunity to face up to one or more of them...as this allegation has come back to me often enough to cause me to think that someone has been spreading it systematically and possibly with malice. But the allegation always reaches me at least secondhand and never with the name of the person. Will you tell me where you got this allegation? I would like to track down this “Scarlet Pimpernel” and get him to hold still long enough to ask him what he is up to and why.

Now for some background on STRANGER and my stories in general: I write for the following reasons

1. To support myself and my family;

2. To entertain my readers;

3. And, if possible, to cause my readers to think.

The first two of these reasons are indispensable, and constitute, together, a commonplace market transaction. I have always had to work for a living, for myself and now for my dependents, and I come from a poor, country family-root, hog, or die. I have worked at many things, but I discovered, somewhat by accident, that I could produce a saleable commodity-entertainment in the form of fiction.

I don’t know why I have this talent; no other member of my family or relatives seem to have it. But I got into it for a reason that many writers have-it was what I could do at the time, i.e., I have been ill for long periods throughout my life, and writing is something a person can do when he is not physically able to take a 9-to-5 job. (Someday I would like to find time to do an essay on this. The cases range from blind Homer to consumptive R.L. Stevenson and are much more numerous than English professors seem to be aware of.)

But if a writer does not entertain his readers all he is producing is paper dirty on one side. I must always bear in mind that my prospective reader could spend his recreation money on beer rather than on my stories; I have to be aware every minute that I am competing for beer money-and that the customer does not have to buy. If I produced, let us say, potatoes or beef, I could be sure that my product had some value in the market. But a story that the customers do not enjoy reading is worth nothing.

So, when anyone asks me why I write, if it is a quick answer, standing up, I simply say, “For money.” Any other short answer is dishonest-and any writer who forgets that his prime purpose is to wangle, say, 95c out of a customer who need not buy at all simply does not get published. He is not a writer; he just thinks he is.

(Oh, surely, one hears a lot of crap about “art,” and “self-expression,” and “duty to mankind”-but when it comes down to the crunch, there your book is, on the newsstands, along with hundreds of others with just as pretty covers-and the customer does not have to buy. If a writer fails to entertain, he fails to put food on the table-and there is no unemployment insurance for freelance writers.)

(Even a wealthy writer has this necessity to be entertaining. Oh, he could indulge in vanity publication at his own expense-but who reads a vanity publication? One’s mother, maybe.)

That covers the first two reasons: I write for money because I have a household to support and in order to earn that money I must entertain the reader.

The third reason is more complex. A writer can afford to indulge in it only if he clears the first two hurdles. I have written almost every sort of thing-filler paragraphs, motion picture & TV scripts, poetry, technical reports, popular journalistic non-fiction, detective stories, love stories, adventure stories, etc.-and I have been paid for 99% of what I have written.

But most of the categories above bored me. I had enough skill to make them pay but I really did not enjoy the work. I found that what I did enjoy and did best was speculative fiction. I do not think that this is just a happy coincidence; I suspect that, with most people, the work they do best is the work they enjoy.

By the time I wrote STRANGER I had enough skills in how to entertain a reader and a solid enough commercial market to risk taking a flyer, a fantasy speculation a bit farther out than I had usually done in the past. My agent was not sure of it, neither was my wife, nor my publisher, but I felt that it would sell at least well enough that the publisher would not lose money on it-would “make his nut.”

I was right, it did catch hold. Its entertainment values were sufficient to carry the parable, even if it was read strictly as entertainment.

But I thought that the parables in it would take hold, too, at least for some readers. They did. Some readers (many, I should say) have told me that they have read this fantasy three, four, five, or more times-in which case it can’t be the story line; there is no element of surprise left in the story line in a work of fiction read over and over again; it has to be something more.

Well, what was I trying to say in it?

I was asking questions.

I was not giving answers. I was trying to shake the reader loose from some preconceptions and induce him to think for himself, along new and fresh lines. In consequence each reader gets something different out of that book because he himself supplies the answers.

If I managed to shake him loose from some prejudice, preconception, or unexamined assumption, that was all I intended to do. A rational human being does not need answers, spoonfed to him on “faith,” he needs questions to worry over-serious ones. The quality of the answers then depends on him...and he may revise those answers several times in the cours3 of a long life (hopefully) getting a little closer to the truth each time. But I would never undertake to be a “Prophet,” handing out neatly packaged answers to lazy minds.

(For some of the more important unanswered questions in STRANGER see chapter XXXIII, especially p.350 of the hardcover, the paragraph starting: “All names belong in the hat, Ben.”)

STARSHIP TROOPERS is loaded with unanswered questions, too. Many people rejected that book with a cliche-”fascist,” or “militaristic.” They can’t or won’t read; it is neither. It is a dead serious (but incomplete) inquiry on why men fight. Since men do fight, it is a question well worth asking.

My latest book, I WILL FEAR NO EVIL, is even more loaded with serious, unanswered questions-perhaps too laden; the story line sags a little. But the questions are dead serious-because, if they remain unanswered, we wind up dead. It does not affect me personally too much, at least not in this life, as I will probably be dead before the present trends converge in major catastrophe.

Nevertheless I worry about them. I think we are in a real bind...and that the answers are not to be found in simplistic “nature communes,” nor in “Zero Population Growth” which does not embrace the entire globe. There may be no answers fully satisfactory...and even incomplete answers will be very difficult.

I find that I have written an essay to myself rather than a letter. Forgive me-perhaps I have reached the age at which one maunders. But I hope I have convinced you that STRANGER is dead serious...as questions. Serious, non-trivial questions, on which a man might spend a lifetime. (And I almost have.)

But anyone who takes that book as answers is cheating himself. It is an invitation to think-not to believe. Anyone who takes it as a license to screw as he pleases is taking a risk; Mrs. Grundy is not dead. Or any other sharp affront to the contemporary culture done publicly-there are stern warnings in it about the dangers involved. Certainly “Do as thou wilt is the whole of the Law” is correct when looked at properly-in fact it is a law of nature, not an injunction, nor a permission. But it is necessary to remember that it applies to everyone-including lynch mobs. The Universe is what It is, and It never forgives mistakes-not even ignorant ones.

I enjoy both Robert Rimmer and Ayn Rand, but I think they are involved in quite a different activity from mine. (I may be mistaken.) I think they give answers, rather than asking questions. It seems to me that their novels are intended to propagandize specific answers. If true, they work toward other ends and by other methods than mine. I do not quarrel with either of them; I am simply not engaged in the same activity.

I would be interested in knowing more about you and your family if you so choose. So far, I know only that you were a freshman at Westminster and that you are High Priest of your church. I suspect that you do not make your living from your priestly work. So?

No man lives in a vacuum; I will be interested in anything you wish to tell me about your life, the Old Religion, your daily work—anything.

I have been seriously ill much of the past two years—and when I was not laid up, Mrs. Heinlein was. But at present we are each in fair shape for our ages. I should have been dead at least twice in the past, so I have no complaints...except that old age can be a damned nuisance in cutting down one’s efficiency. Nevertheless, with luck, I will start another book soon.

All good wishes to you and yours,

Robert A. Heinlein

***

Robert A. Heinlein to Oberon (Tim) Zell, 2/28/72 (This entire letter, including my letter to him to which this was in reply, was printed in Green Egg Vol. XXII, No. 85; Beltane, 1989)

...In the course of the past thirty years I have answered many thousands of letters from strangers. Only since I became seriously ill in 1969 have I stopped writing personal answers to the great mass of mail I receive. Most letters now get a printed form reply, signed by Mrs. Heinlein--yours was one of the ca. 1% I picked out to answer myself...

Re the GREEN EGG--you and anyone else are of course free to make any comment at all on my published and copyrighted works; any writer must expect this... Only my copyrighted and published works are a fit subject for public comment... My reason?

Because I’ve been “nibbled to death by ducks,” that’s why!

I have learned the hard way to avoid such publicity whenever possible. It results in unsolicited correspondence, usually dull and always time consuming--and some of it will come from crackpots who will then publish my answer in some fan magazine and the cycle starts all over again. Years ago, when some fan editor published an article about me, I would usually acknowledge with a polite letter. It took me a while to learn that he would then print it--without permission. I learned... I think I should add that the GREEN EGG is not a fan magazine in my opinion...

Enough--it all adds up to the fact that I have too much to do and only a few years at most to do it in, and I will not let my remaining time be wasted by importune strangers each of whom wants just a little slice of my life. I have more important things to do with what time I can spare from work, such as playing with our cats, watching quail and deer, and enjoying sunsets. I learned (Ginny saw it first, but in time I was forced to agree with her) that, unless we adopted a very firm line, endless hordes of strangers would demand “just a little” of my time to the point where I would not only never get any writing done but also she and I would never have any time to ourselves in which simply to savor life and enjoy the company of our friends. So now I am a nasty son of a bitch who simply will not do anything--unless it suits me. (SISL--Jubal to Jill: “So now I do what pleasures Jubal Harshaw.”)

I do enjoy corresponding with you. You give at least as much as you get. I’m sorry I don’t have the time to write more frequently; I enjoy your letters...

Again, your letter—SISL was never censored by anyone in any fashion. The first draft was nearly twice as long as the published version. I cut it myself to bring it down to a commercial length. But I did not leave out anything of any importance; I simply trimmed all possible excess verbiage. Perhaps you have noticed that it reads “fast” despite its length; that is why. I WILL FEAR NO EVIL does not read as “fast” because it never received its final trimming; I became extremely ill and could not do it, and would not allow an editor to do it because my stories are fitted together like jigsaw puzzles and it is awfully easy, in trimming, to leave out an essential piece. So I WILL FEAR NO EVIL is not as good a story as SISL, in my opinion--too slow--even though, again in my opinion, what I have said in it is just as important. But I’m pleased enough that I was able to finish it at all; it just missed being posthumous. (Mrs. Heinlein signed the contract; I was too far gone even to write my signature.)

The original, longest version of SISL is in a fireproof vault of the library of UCSC and can be seen there by any scholar who convinces the special collection librarian that he has a legitimate interest. But it is really not worth your trouble, as it is the same story throughout--simply not as well told. With it is the brushpenned version which shows exactly what was cut out--nothing worth reading, that is. I learned to write for pulp magazines, in which one was paid by the yard rather than by the package; it was not until I started writing for the Saturday Evening Post that I learned the virtue of brevity. (And I am still too wordy in a private communication such as this, or in conversation.)

Thanks for THE ORIGIN OF ATL and THE FULTON YEARS. I have read them three times and will file them with your letters and my file of the GREEN EGG, and will be interested in reading the rest when you send it...

I do not take the GREEN EGG because I am hipped on SISL (Good grief, I wrote that book) but because it gives me a new perspective. I read great masses of periodicals from as wide a variety of viewpoints as possible, from THE BLACK PANTHER to an extremely conservative magazine, from yours to a Fundamentalist organ called THE PLAIN TRUTH, several so-called “underground” papers, three ordinary dailies, including the Wall Street Journal, a wide variety of technical and scientific journals, from time to time foreign publications in several languages, a magazine called THE FUTURIST (I am a member of its society and so is Robert Rimmer, Herman Kahn, Arthur C. Clarke, et al) (must quit, I’m tired), several military journals, aerospace journals, and many others--as wide a spectrum as I can find.

I read the GREEN EGG because it has in it things I do not find elsewhere.

I find this true also of your letters, which is why I enjoy them. But I notice that your letters make no mention of the Craft while the GREEN EGG does. I have many books on Arcane matters--some traditional, some phony as hell. I am not inquiring into any private matters of CAW...but I do find interesting a publicly-avowed church which seems to be founded on the Wise Craft, or the Old Religion, or whatever term you prefer. So I read what you send me; it gives me a new point of view...

All good wishes,

                                                                           Robert A. Heinlein


Oberon Zell (photo from official website). 

No comments: